Wednesday, January 18, 2012

Robert Bloch on TV Part Seven-Alfred Hitchcock Presents: "The Gloating Place"

Susan Harrison as Susan 
by Jack Seabrook

“The Gloating Place” marked the second time that Robert Bloch adapted one of his own stories for Alfred Hitchcock Presents. The first had been “The Changing Heart.” The story is one of subtle horror, where Bloch uses slang and the perspective of a teenager’s mind to diffuse the terrible things that are happening. This has two effects—it makes the events more palatable while demonstrating the callous evil of the vapid teenage girl who is the story’s protagonist.

The masked killer approaches.
Susan Harper, a high school student, goes to her gloating place, “a small ravine at the far end of the park where she could sit without being noticed or disturbed.” Right away, we learn what kind of person she is: she wishes that her parents would die in a plane crash so that she could receive insurance money. “She was alone and nobody ever paid any attention to her,” so a week before she had claimed that a man had attacked her in a vacant lot. The result “had been a real gasser,” since she began to receive attention from classmates, her family and police. When she had to identify a suspect in a police lineup, it was “the dreamiest-creamiest of all.”

When a car accident results in “three cars wrecked and two people killed,” she is upset because it diverts attention from her. Bloch describes her: “the fat, foreshortened body, the plump, pimply face, the hair the color of the brown, muddy water.” She admits to herself that the biggest reason for her lie was “to get Tom Reynolds to notice her.” In order to regain the attention she craves, she hatches a plan and murders Marjorie, Tom’s girlfriend. Bloch does not describe the actual murder; what happened only becomes evident later, as the story is filtered through Susan’s shallow, teenage mind. 

Susan reaches out to grab Marjorie.
Once again the center of attention, Susan wants some time to herself, so she sneaks off to the gloating place, where she recalls carrying out Marjorie’s murder, strangling the girl until she was “just a big, boneless pig doll that was no good to Tom Reynolds or to anybody.” She gazes at her own reflection in the water, certain that she has not changed, now comforted by her familiarly ugly appearance. Just then, she sees the reflection of a man behind her, as his gloved hands “closed over her throat.”

Bloch's story is one of subtle but powerful horror, in which a killer gets her comeuppance in a twist ending. He had a difficult challenge in adapting the story for television, since the tale is told mostly through the thoughts of the main character. The script is passable, but there are some problems with the program that make it one of the less successful Bloch/Hitchcock efforts thus far. The first, and probably the biggest, problem is the casting of the lead. Susan is played by Susan Harrison, an actress probably best known for playing the ballerina on the Twilight Zone episode, "Five Characters in Search of an Exit." She was born in 1938, making her 22 or 23 years old when “The Gloating Place” was filmed in the spring of 1961. Harrison is too pretty to play the Susan of the story, and her acting abilities are not equal to the task of explaining why such an attractive young woman would be so psychologically damaged as to commit the crimes she does. In the story, Bloch describes her as ugly and unpopular, but in the show, she just seems odd. The rest of the cast is not much better. Worst of all is Erin O’Brien-Moore, as Susan’s mother, whose histrionics seem out of place with the rest of the low key acting on exhibit. 


The most interesting cast note is that Marjorie, the girl Susan kills, is played by a very young Marta Kristen. Born in 1945 and aged 15 or 16 when this was filmed, Kristen’s coltish beauty is perfectly suited to her role. She would later become famous as Judy Robinson on Lost in Space, and she still makes appearances and has her own website. One other interesting cast note is that one of the other high school girls is played by Monica Henreid, daughter of actor/director Paul Henreid, who directed "The Landlady," Bloch’s prior script for this series.


“The Gloating Place” was directed by Alan Crosland, Jr., who lived from 1918 to 2001 and directed scores of episodes of series television, including 20 for the Hitchcock series. The first time I watched the show, I was disappointed in how it had been adapted from the printed page, and I thought that the director might be to blame. However, on re-watching it, I noticed a number of interesting camera setups and lighting choices. The scenes at the gloating place are filmed by contrasting shots of Susan with shots of her reflection in a pool of water. When she first has the idea to fake having been attacked, the voices of her classmates echo around her as the camera cuts and pans from one eerie, leafless tree to the next. The effect shows just how alone Susan feels. 

Marta Kristen in "The Gloating Place"
Marta Kristen on Lost in Space
Susan reflected in the glass at the lineup.
Another nicely filmed sequence is the lineup in the police station. Susan and the policemen sit behind one way glass and the room is lit in a high contrast, noir style.

The last sequence is effectively planned, shot and edited to show a brutal attack on a young woman without really showing anything, and it is thus very effective and almost daring for a network television program in 1961. 

The final twist.
“The Gloating Place” was first published in the June 1959 issue of Rogue and it was reprinted in Blood Runs Cold (1961) and Bitter Ends (1990). The television adaptation was broadcast on NBC on Tuesday, May 16, 1961, at 8:30 on the East Coast. It was up against The Many Loves of Dobie Gillis, another teen-oriented show, on CBS, and at 9 o’clock on NBC, the “Terror in Teakwood” episode of Thriller aired, directed by Paul Henreid, whose daughter had appeared in “The Gloating Place.”

The show was remade for the 1980s revival of Alfred Hitchcock Presents and broadcast on January 5, 1986; it can be viewed here. The original episode is not yet available on DVD but can be viewed here.

Sources: 


Bloch, Robert. "The Gloating Place." Bitter Ends: The Complete Stories of Robert Bloch, Volume Two. New York, NY: Citadel, 1990. 257-64. Print. 

Galactic Central. Web. 16 Jan. 2012. <http://philsp.com/>.  "The Gloating Place." Alfred Hitchcock Presents. NBC. 16 May 1961. Television.  Grams, Martin, and Patrik Wikstrom. The Alfred Hitchcock Presents Companion. Churchville, MD: OTR Pub., 2001. Print. The Internet Movie Database (IMDb). Web. 16 Jan. 2012. <http://www.imdb.com/>. Marta Kristen - The Official Website. Web. 16 Jan. 2012. <http://martakristen.com>. Wikipedia. Web. 16 Jan. 2012. <http://www.wikipedia.org/>.


27 comments:

Peter Enfantino said...

Another great installment, Jack. I'd be talking to the people at McFarland if I were you about compiling a book when this series is all done. Bloch is my favorite writer, as I think I've said countless times, and I thought the same thing watching this for the first time years ago (shortly after reading the story) about our devilish girl looking nothing like what Bloch imagined. That was TV then (and TV now actually): the dame has to be a doll!

Jack Seabrook said...

Thanks, Peter! I did not know Bloch was your favorite writer. It's interesting to track his development as a TV writer by following this series--these are some of his earliest teleplays.

Randall Larson said...

This is an excellent series, Jack,and I'm glad to read your latest commentary. Peter is right - when you're done this needs to be a book!

Peter Enfantino said...

Coming from the world's preeminent expert on Robert Bloch, that's quite the compliment!

Jack Seabrook said...

Thanks for the encouragement, Randall!

JC Harding said...

By sheer coincidence I just saw this episode tonight and I thought Susan Harrison was quite a cutie, acting talent notwithstanding.
Since I'd never heard of her before (and we are close to the same age) I did an internet search which revealed she now lives in Carbondale, IL.
In case anyone is interested . .

Jack Seabrook said...

Yes, she was far more attractive than the character as described in Bloch's story. Thanks for reading!

Mike Doran said...

Better late than never ...

Actually, there's one role Susan Harrison played that I always thought was her best known:

She was Burt Lancaster's sister in Sweet Smell Of Success.

Of course, after Lancaster and Tony Curtis got finished dining out on each other in that, there was scarcely anything left for anyone else ...

Jack Seabrook said...

I would love to hear from someone why this particular post is attracting such a lot of interest!

Grant said...

Marta Kristen was also the mermaid in BEACH BLANKET BINGO. Her sub-plot with Jody McCrea was almost a comical answer to the movie NIGHT TIDE.

Jack Seabrook said...

I don't think I've ever made it through an entire Beach movie, but they have some pretty weird aspects. Thanks for pointing this out!

Grant said...

I've never stopped being attached to them (though I set my copies aside till the late Spring and early Summer), so I'm always glad to be helpful with that subject.

Unknown said...

The 1986 remake is better. :-)

Jack Seabrook said...

I'll have to take your word for it!

Jett said...

The 1986 remake is good too.SPOILER ALERT!A young teen girl is killed by a stalker.Charismatic TV crime reporter Carl Cansino covers it and gawky,shy,introverted teen Susan watches it and gets an idea! She fakes an attack and gets the attention she craves from her cold yuppie parents,her peers (Tom,a boy who kind of likes her wants to walk her home) and the media.Suave Carl interviews her and charms her out of her shell and expressed interest in her art and ambition to see the world.He is happy to be let into her world.The,another girl is attacked! Susan's classmate Debbie Spooner.She says she stabbed the masked assailant in tbe neck with her hair beret and got away.Susan becomes enraged that all eyes are on Debbie and thinks she's lying.That night there is a storm,and in one unbelievable plot twist,Susan's parents go out to a business dinner and leave her alone,with a killer loose that just"attacked"her a few days ago?! Anyway,Febbie shows up and screams that the killer is after them.I know there were no cell phones in 1986,but she comes there instead of going to a house with more cars!? Susan calls her a liar and finally admits she made up her attack.Debbie calls her sick and lets Susan throw her out,then she screams to be let back in.Susan finally opens the door and sees Debbie is stabbed to death and nailed to the door! She screams and runs and suddenly Carl is at the back door and says he's back to i rearview her more.He checks the house and she follows him upstairs and suddenly.... SPOILER ALERT...he appears and grabs her by the throat and says he is the killer and she should never have lied about being attacked."Now you have to become part of the story!"Then he strangles her to death and breaks her neck and drops her dead body to the floor.The next day,Carl is on the spot to report the story as Susan's and Debbie's bodies as they are carried out and he says he feels personally responsible.A nerdy,geeky bespectacled young teen girl is watching the story on the news with her family and suddenly grins... She's got an idea! How about if I fake an attack...? Here we go again!Obviously this isn't a continuing trend since Debbie was really attacked,but it it might not be a good idea to lie and say your local serial killer attacked you!! You know what they say about self-fulfilling prophecies!

Jett said...

One way Susan could see that Carl was the killer was that he had a hole in his neck where Debbie stabbed him with her beret earlier.

Jett said...

I meant interview her more,not rearview her more.LOL Sorry

Jett said...

Let me rephrase that.That wasn't a self-fulfilling prophecy.You know what they say about tempting fate!

Jack Seabrook said...

Thanks, Jett! That sounds entertaining.

crotonjoe said...

The cold open for this episode shows Hitchcock as a soda jerk with two high school pendants hanging behind him ... one for Lincoln High, the other for Kennedy High School. Broadcast 16MAY1961, they have a high school named after Kennedy -- certainly filmed soon after his inauguration. And the juxtaposition foreshadows all those Lincoln / Kennedy coincidences!

Jack Seabrook said...

That's interesting that there would be a Kennedy High pennant while he was still in office. Thanks for reading!

john kenrick said...

Thanks for reviewing this episode and your analysis of it. I've seen it now maybe three times, and I enjoyed it the least the last time I watched it the other night5. The writing wasn't up to the story, and the dialogue rang hollow. Susan Harrison's performance in the lead failed to convince. It was for me a matter of miscasting. Yes, she was too good looking for the part, though if a good enough actress she should have been able to have aced it. Jessica Tandy's refined beauty did not sink or even seriously mar The Glass Eye. She had the chops for it, and while no plain jane, who else could have done it better? Something just plain went wrong with The Gloating Place. It's like someone was asleep at the switch.

Jack Seabrook said...

Thanks, John. I haven't watched this in almost a decade, since I wrote about it, but I remember thinking it wasn't very good. Oddly enough, this is one of our most popular posts. I have no idea why.

john kenrick said...

It's always good to read your posts, Jack. Funny what's popular on the Web and what isn't (as you must know what goes on at the Yuku CHFB). This is seldom predictable.

As to the schools with names like Kennedy and Lincoln, well, neither is that common a name; nor are they rare. I suppose neither could have been named after the president who bears that last name.

There was a popular New England novelist named Joseph Lincoln whose books were still popular (among the older seventy crowd) circa 1980-81, and I had clients and customers who read him. (Strangely, there was a New Hampshire born novelist who bore the name Winston Churchill who was held in high esteem in literary circles,--and yes, he was a very distant cousin of the British PM, and actually met him once, way before the Battle Of Britain, I assume).

As to the Kennedy and Lincoln connection, I recommend a 1951 film, a thriller, The Tall Target, and starring Dick Powell playing a N.Y. railroad detective named John Kennedy, whose job was to stop the plot to assassinate the still President-elected Abraham Lincoln on the train ride to NYC. He succeeded, as you might imagine. What's remarkable about the film is that it was based on a true story; and yes, the detective was indeed a man named John Kennedy. I should probably stop now (do look this up, though).

Jack Seabrook said...

I will look that up! Thanks!

don said...

Great job as always! It came out on DVD in the interim 12 years because I have it. BTW, it is the worst packaging I have ever seen -- episodes are not listed on the discs or the cover, and the discs refuse to stay locked down. For shame, Universal!

But that's not why I'm here. I agree, Susan Harrison was too pretty for this role. But it is really bugging me who she looks like. The best I can come up with is Kate Mara who I know from a few episodes of 24 (although she has done many other things). Coincidentally she also played a falsely-accusing nutjob on 24.

I see people are still finding your post. If anyone has a better suggestion after a fresh viewing, please help! Keep up the great work!

Jack Seabrook said...

Thanks! I can't find where Universal ever released season 7 in US format. I know what you mean about an actor or actress reminding you of someone. I had that happen recently but won't embarrass myself by saying who.