The Marvel/Atlas
Horror Comics
Horror Comics
Part 140
March 1957 Part II
by Peter Enfantino
and Jack Seabrook
Cover by Bill Everett
"How High is High?" (a: Paul Reinman) ★
"The Door to...?" (a: Gray Morrow) ★
"Which Face is Mine?" (a: Syd Shores) ★1/2
"The Secret Formula!" (a: Ed Winiarski) ★
"Sounds in the Night!" (a: Angelo Torres) ★
"Forbidden... Keep Out!" (a: Mac L. Pakula) ★★1/2
Famous architect J. R. Alton talks a construction crew into building a two-mile-high skyscraper but one of the builders becomes suspicious when he overhears Alton talking to a mysterious voice from another planet. The voice reveals that the plan is to build several tall skyscrapers to throw the Earth off its axis. Then the invading warriors of planet Kotto will swoop in and take over. But Alton's plans go awry when his fellow Kottoians desert him. "How High is High?" is a meandering mess that requires a massive suspension of disbelief.
In the three-page "The Door to...?," a hypnotist is called in to help a high-level prison beef up its security by fooling its inmates into believing the complex is the promised land. Equally vacuous is "Which Face is Mine?," wherein a thief learns how to change his facial features thanks to an arcane spell. After pulling a heist, the crook flees from the police and changes his face to elude capture, only to inadvertently switch to the guise of a wanted felon. "Shoot on sight!" screams the wanted poster and the cops do.
Paul finds a book on alchemy and rushes back to the shabby home he shares with his two buddies, Ralph and Chuck, sure he's found the key to Midas's fortune. Luckily, Ralph is a chemist who quickly whips up "The Secret Formula!" that enables the man who drinks it to visit the future. Ralph takes the jump a year into the future and discovers that old man Craig, who lives down the road apiece, is sitting on a worthless piece of farm acreage that hides a huge deposit of oil.
Ralph returns to his body and tells his buddies they must buy the land pronto and then sell it at a premium, but one more visit to the farm is Ralph's undoing as he falls for Farmer Craig's gorgeous daughter and cannot go through with the deception. Paul and Ralph decide to kill Paul before he can disclose the master plan, but their evil plot backfires. If you paid attention to my star rating up top, there's no secret that "The Secret Formula!" is a stiff, but I almost recommend a reading just to experience the goofiness and complexity of its final panels.
Young Seth Collins panics and deserts his military squad during the War of 1812, then spends the rest of his life hearing the calls of his comrades. Seth grows old and soon his grandson, Roy, enlists. It's at that time that the cries in Seth's head disappear. He's found peace at last now that his grandson has volunteered to sacrifice his own life. Tedious and moronic, "Sounds in the Night!" is comprised mostly of panels of Seth looking depressed and his wife begging him to tell her what's up. The jingoistic climax is 100% pure Wessler (with perhaps a nudge from Stan "Stinkin' Commies!" Lee). The Torres art is nice to look at, but if you put a dress on a pig...
Easily the Best of the Issue Award goes to "Forbidden... Keep Out!," a simple but effective undersea adventure. Doctor Lane and his gorgeous daughter, Sharon, have come to a remote Pacific island in search of "a race of underwater men" living somewhere near the island. Sharon can't help but blunder into danger after danger until she's rescued by two handsome, virile examples of male machismo, George and Phil, who volunteer to help the Lanes with their research.
After a couple more mishaps (including a "herd" of attacking sharks!), the doctor throws in the towel and suggests that perhaps there are things man is not supposed to know... or something along those lines. As George and Phil wave goodbye, Dr. Lane wonders how the two men got to an island one thousand miles from civilization without a boat. I loved that last line and, believe it or not, never put two and two together until it was spelled out. An enjoyable little yarn with some swell Mac Pakula cheesecake art saves Marvel Tales #156 from being a total failure.-Peter
Mystery Tales #51
Cover by Bill Everett
"Inside the Mummy's Case" (a: Joe Orlando) ★
(r: Journey Into Mystery #16)
"The Lizard" (a: Al Williamson & Ralph Mayo (?)) ★★1/2
"What World is This?" (a: Ross Andru & Mike Esposito) ★
(r: Vault of Evil #18)
"The Strange Seeds!" (a: Ed Winiarski) ★1/2
"I'll Get You Later" (a: Dave Berg) ★
"Four Empty Chairs!" (a: Marvin Stein) ★
(r: Uncanny Tales #9)
Museum guard Joe Waters is receiving telepathic messages from within the coffin of a centuries-dead pharaoh, promising endless wealth if Joe will only lift the coffin lid. Just in time, the museum's curator stops Joe from making a terrible mistake and both watch as a deadly booby trap is triggered. Now, together the two men will destroy the evil force "Inside the Mummy's Case"! Dreadfully dull fantasy ends with a cliffhanger, but that's okay... I don't need another page.
The sharp Williamson/Mayo art is pretty much the only reason to wade through "The Lizard," about a scientist who climbs into the Tibetan mountains to work on his "growth accelerator," an invention that will (naturally) benefit mankind. His test subject, a cute little lizard, is splashed with the growth serum during a raging storm and escapes into the mountains, terrorizing the populace before our egghead tracks it down. But, no worries, it was all the obligatory dream and now the big brain must decide whether to push on with the test or heed the warning. This is post-code, so we all know which path he ventured down.
Fleeing from the cops, Cole stumbles into a town of frozen people. "What World is This?" mumbles the moronic thief, not bothering to inspect the still-life figures closer. If he had, he'd notice they're all dummies and he's entered a faux town set up for an atomic bomb testing. Whoops! This plot had been swirling around the Atlas bowl for years and every now and then got plucked for use. The awful Andru/Esposito art certainly doesn't help matters much.
Sentenced by the stinkin' commie Russkies to twenty years' hard labor in Siberia, peacenik Ivan Lenov has little hope for the future until Mars has a terrible space storm and shoots seeds at Earth. "The Strange Seeds!" land right in Ivan's garden and he tends them carefully. A few months later, plant men rise from the soil and inform Ivan that they're forever in his debt and will grant him any wish he speaks. Wanting only to see the downfall of the dictator, Ivan asks his new friends to get rid of the prison guards. That wish granted, the walking foliage return for further instructions. Unfortunately, Ivan learns he aimed too low as the snow falls and the Martians wilt away. New guards are assigned and life in the Russkie wasteland resumes its tiring schedule. But, he realizes, the sun will return some day and so will the plants. This Winiarski-led snoozer culminates in one of the obligatory Atlas freedom speeches of the mid-50s.
Perpetual loser Barney Beale finds a briefcase filled with dough, twenty grand to be exact, on his kitchen table. Inside, a note explains that the case is from five years in the future and Barney can have two thousand bucks if he leaves the rest alone. The future friend will be coming back for the rest. But who is the future friend? If you've read any Atlas SF/fantasy time travel yarns, you know who wrote the note before the first page is turned. Dave Berg usually contributed solid graphic work, but his art on "I'll Get You Later" is primitive and ugly.
A truly awful issue of Mystery Tales comes to a truly awful finish with "Four Empty Chairs!," the story of an old man in a mansion who dines with the titular furniture every night. The town gossips want to know what's going on, so they hire a lip reader to have a look. Do you really need me to go on? Well, the old man and his invisible family are aliens waiting to be struck by lightning bolts so they can go back to their home world. Their dream comes true and the town really has something to talk about. Hey, you wanted me to go on. But now I'm done!-Peter
Mystic #57
Cover by Bill Everett
"Trapped in the Ant Hill!" (a: Syd Shores) ★★
"The Midnight Visitor!" (a: Mac L. Pakula) ★1/2
(r: Chamber of Chills #20)
"The Strange Prison!" (a: Bill Everett) ★★1/2
(r: Where Monsters Dwell #37)
"He'd Rather Die Than Tell" (a: Ed Winiarski) ★
"The Room of Shadows!" (a: Robert Q. Sale) ★
"You Can't Hide from the Eye!" (a: Joe Orlando) ★1/2
A scientist named Perry Moore invents a serum that temporarily shrinks living tissue. He accidentally cuts his arm and some serum enters his bloodstream, causing him to reduce to the size of an ant. Outside, he is frightened of the threatening bugs and crawls into a hole, only to find himself "Trapped in the Ant Hill!" Perry observes ants trying to develop a serum to grow to the size of humans, whom they hate, and when he reverts to normal size he vows to devote himself to finding a new way to kill ants.
Syd Shores does a decent job of depicting tiny Dr. Moore and the big insects he encounters. My favorite sequence is when he discovers the ant laboratory, with diagrams of ants and humans and a very frustrated ant scientist.
Leon Aymler is an author who is hard at work on his book when he's interrupted by "The Midnight Visitor!" The strange man holds a gun on Leon and demands to know how he learned everything in his book. Leon insists it's fiction but the visitor shows him that it's not and that he's the traitor whose story Leon told. Leon begs for time to write a sequel in which the villain is caught and punished and the visitor agrees, certain that it won't come true, but as soon as Leon writes that FBI men entered and captured the traitor, it comes to pass. Leon and the visitor both faint due to the sudden shock.
Though the visitor insists that there's nothing supernatural going on here, the opposite proves to be the case. The uncredited author provides no explanation as to why the words Leon write come true and I had to think, as I was reading, that if I were the traitor, I would not have let Leon take the time to write a brief sequel in which I got caught. Why risk it?
Tad Branton is new to skin diving and passes out the first time he tries it. He awakens in the Underwater World, where he is given the tour by a gorgeous gal named Pisca, who happens to be the daughter of the king. The man who marries her will receive a chest of treasure, so Tad does the usual Atlas thing, marrying her and then swimming to the surface with his treasure. Oddly, his boat is floating right where he left it, but Tad can't breathe air and passes out. This time he wakes up behind the bars of "The Strange Prison!" It seems the king had doctors operate on Tad so he can only breathe water, not air. Now that he's screwed up, he'll spend two years in the underwater slammer before another operation makes him able to breathe air again and he's returned to the surface world. Oh, and the treasure chest? It was full of shells, which are priceless underwater!
Sadly, Bill Everett is only given three pages in which to work in this story, but they allow him to draw mostly underwater panels, which are colored blue and black and hearken back to his days drawing the Sub-Mariner for Timely. It always cracks me up when the underwater babes are wearing bikinis; this one's top is made of two strategically placed seashells.
Why does Andrew Korvak run through Spain, France, and Italy tightly clutching a black box and never letting go? "He'd rather die than tell." Finally falling to his death from a roof, Andrew reveals that the box contains an indestructible crystal ball that shows a picture of his crime--robbing and murdering the gypsy who owned the orb! Ed Winiarski's art is mediocre, as usual, but this story is odd in that there is no dialogue save for two panels on the final page, where Korvak reveals that the crystal ball was indestructible. The story is told in captions and wordless panels, which is not a bad thing. Many Atlas stories could do with fewer words.
After years of searching, Beldick finally locates "The Room of Shadows!" in the Cambodian jungle. All his assistants desert him but he doesn't care, since he knows that, inside the room, he'll be granted three wishes. Beldick pushes past the temple priest, who insists that his wishes will come to naught, and reaches the room. His first wish is to be the wisest man in the world, but Beldick is not happy to inhabit the body of a sick old man. His second wish is to be as rich as Croesus, but when he is given the ancient king's wealth he understands that it holds little value today and is too heavy to move. A match carelessly tossed aside starts a fire and Beldick's last wish is wasted on preserving his life from the flames.
Robert Q. Sale's art isn't getting any better, is it! This story is yet another variation on "The Monkey's Paw," and every reader old enough to read knows full well what's going to happen long before page four arrives.
"You Can't Hide from the Eye!" is the bitter lesson that Floyd Ryder learns after he invents a super high frequency TV camera that can look through walls and see things far away. He makes a deal with a gangster to let the crook use the camera to look into banks and witness safe combinations, but after a series of successful robberies the police arrest Floyd, who did not realize that what he saw on his screen was also being broadcast to every TV set in the city!
An uneven issue of Mystic ends with a dud. Even Joe Orlando can't enliven this snoozer, in which TV is both the source of wealth and the downfall of a greedy inventor.-Jack
![]() |
| Next Week... Is Our Special No-Content Holiday Issue But in Two Weeks... A Shocker From Reed Crandall! |





















































