The Critical Guide to
the Warren Illustrated Magazines
1964-1983
by Uncle Jack
& Cousin Peter
Bode/Todd |
"The Fade-Away Walk" ★★
Story by Don McGregor
Art by Tom Sutton
"The Impersonation!" ★★
Story by Steve Skeates
Art by Pablo Marcos
"Swamp Demon" ★1/2
Story & Art by Dave Cockrum
"The Disintegrator" ★1/2
Story by Nick Cuti
Art by Ken Barr
"Lost and Found" ★
Story by Steve Skeates
Art by George Roussos
"Dual Dragon" ★★
Story and Art by Gary Kaufman
Tarrant, the last man on Earth, walks through the rubble of South Dakota, looking for something to keep him alive. He finds what's left of a nuclear power plant and heads inside, discovering a wall of protective suits. As he's donning one, he notices the empty space where a suit once hung and realizes he's not alone after all. When he heads back onto the street, his only mission becomes to find the elusive second last man standing but, unfortunately for our protagonist, the guy has found him first. Barely dodging a laser blast from a "thermal ray" gun, Tarrant must flee for his life, eventually winding up at Mount Rushmore, where (for some unknown reason) he climbs to the top. His assailant follows him and, when they come face to face, reveals that he's out to kill Tarrant because of his skin color. In the end, the man lets Tarrant fall to his death and then ponders life's inequalities.
"The Fade-Away Walk" |
"The Impersonation!" |
"The Impersonation!" |
"Swamp Demon!" |
"The Disintegrator" |
"Dual Dragon" |
In "Dual Dragon," a young warrior will do anything he can to win the love of the fair maiden, Inge... even slay a dragon. But what if Inge doesn't want to be won? Gary Kaufman, the writer/artist who so impressed us last issue with "Mad Jack's Girl," doesn't quite hit a bullseye this time out. The art's still stunning (very much akin to Jeff Jones's style), but the script is meandering and blah and the climactic twist is pretty much the same as that of "Swamp Demon!" (which may just be a case of coincidence). Seems as though Warren forgot this magazine is called Creepy, foregoing the horror for an issue stocked with fantasy and science fiction. Not a good trend.-Peter
Jack-The stories in this issue range from mediocre to not quite that good. Sutton's art helps "The Fade-Away Walk," in which Tarrant, like Burgess Meredith on The Twilight Zone, survives an atomic blast because he was underground. The North by Northwest finale comes out of nowhere. Overall, Don McGregor overwrites and the story is overlong and pretentious. "Swamp Demon!" has its moments and continues to show early Dave Cockrum work, though it's impressive in spots. I enjoyed "Lost and Found," probably because it's only five pages long, and the Roussos art reminded me of what we see every other week at Peter's journey through the Atlas catalog.
I lost track of "The Disintegrator" about halfway through and the end came out of nowhere, but Ken Barr's art is not bad. "Dual Dragon" starts out promisingly but meanders and can't sustain its seven-page length; it ends up a disappointment. Worst of all was "The Impersonation!" where Marcos seems to be trying to copy the style of Neal Adams. The story is awful and the climax unsatisfying.
Enrich Torres |
"Retribution"★★
Story by Gardner Fox & Steve Englehart
Art by Steve Englehart
"The Comet's Curse!"★1/2
Story by Buddy Saunders
Art by Frank Brunner
"The Tower of the Demon Dooms!"★★
Story by Gardner Fox
Art by Mike Ploog
"I Am Dead, Egypt, Dead"★★★
Story by Doug Moench
Art by Victor de la Fuente
"Cats and Dogs"★★1/2
Story by Bill DuBay
Art by Jerry Grandenetti
"Money"★★1/2
Story and Art by Sanho Kim
"Retribution" |
An odd story to start this issue of Eerie, this is a tedious six pages that seem much longer. Steve Englehart's art is adequate and certainly better than that of some of the artists we've seen in the pages of the Warren mags, and the fact that he receives co-writing credit with Gardner Fox makes me suspect that he was given a tired Fox script and allowed to revise it while he also illustrated it.
"The Comet's Curse!" |
I like Frank Brunner's art, even in its early stages, but this story is terrible. As with the one before it, six pages seem like sixty! As usual, the proofreading is wretched--in one panel on the first page, Vallen is spelled two different ways! The story makes little sense and is basically an excuse for Brunner to draw a cool skeleton at the end. But no amount of atmospheric panels can rescue storytelling this inept.
"The Tower of the Demon Dooms!" |
What a mess! I am beginning to realize that Warren must have been the training ground for some Marvel talent, with Englehart, Brunner, and Ploog drawing the first three stories in this issue. I was never a big fan of Man-Thing, but I have a memory that Ploog's work was pretty good. Here, it's uneven. In places I see what look like swipes from Eisner as well as attempts to imitate Eisner and, unless I'm crazy, Al Capp. Fox's story is as nutty as the rest of his tales, with names of people and places that are a real chore to decipher.
"Egypt" |
Despite its terrible title, "I Am Dead, Egypt, Dead" is a straightforward and entertaining little story of double crosses and revenge that benefits from very sharp art by Victor de la Fuente. The tale will win a Warren Award in 1972. It succeeds mainly because it turns out not to be so eerie after all; it's really a crime story.
Willie comes home from being in the Army and is welcomed by his Mom, Dad, and little brother, Davey. The siblings used to fight like "Cats and Dogs," but they're all grown up now. Willie notices that the townsfolk seem to be acting strangely, so Davey explains that a werewolf has killed five people! Willie tells Davey that when he was in Sham-Pei, the town was terrorized by a man-leopard! That night, the brothers are about the hit the hay when they reveal (surprise) to each other that they are the werewolf and the man-leopard. From downstairs, their parents hear a lot of noise and remark that the boys are back to their fighting ways.
"Cats and Dogs" |
Many years ago, in Korea, a gambler named Park loses all his money and is about to hang himself when an old man tells him to go back to the gambling house, where money will soon walk out the door. Park is advised to follow it but not to get too close. Sure enough, a big winner walks out and is soon set upon and killed by thieves. The thieves, in turn, are killed by a samurai, who takes the money and rushes to the side of his lover, happy that now they can be wed. In the night, she murders him and runs off with the "Money," only to be robbed by Park, who has been following the loot all this time. He becomes obsessed with the cash, certain that everyone is out to steal it from him. He ends up alone on top of a mountain, guarding his riches.
"Money" |
Peter-Like its sister pubs, Eerie seems to have given over to a predominately fantasy/sword & sorcery bent, which is far from my cup of tea, and if it's not S&S/F, then chances are it'll take place in Egypt. I was thoroughly lost halfway through "Retribution" and then just wished it would be over. Spoiler alert: it does end, eventually. Similarly, "The Comet's Curse!" has a convoluted plot and dopey dialogue but at least it's got some dyn-o-mite graphics by up-and-comer Frank Brunner.
Speaking of rising stars, we get the first appearance (of only four) of Mike Ploog, doomed to realize the aquarium-bottom-quality of Gardner Fox's "The Tower of the Demon Dooms!" a story so full of cringe-worthy prose (In those ancient lands that stretch from Kabblamoth to long-deserted Gagrath...), I thought my brain might forsooth melteth. This is raw Ploog, not yet the skilled comic master who will help redefine Marvel horror comics with Ghost Rider, Werewolf by Night and, especially, The Monster of Frankenstein.
"I Am Dead, Egypt, Dead!" (that sure sounds like something torn from the pages of a Skywald zine) is not bad; it's got approximately 37 twists at its climax and most of them work. This is the first of two stories this month devoted to Ramses. Artist Victor de La Fuente drops in for his only appearance of the 1970s but, oddly, turns up again the following decade for a long run on the series, "Haxur." Jerry Grandenetti returns for the supremely stupid "Cats and Dogs" and gives it one of his melty-sheens. Yeah, the script doesn't make much sense (only because the rules are not laid out for us) but, by golly, it's the only "horror story" you're going to get this issue. "Money." It's a bitch.
Sanjulian |
"The Lurker in the Deep!" ★★
Story by Archie Goodwin
Art by Jose Gonzalez
"From Death's Dark Corner!" ★★
Story by Gerry Conway
Art by Steve Hickman
"The Silver Thief and the Pharoah's Daughter" ★★★
Story by Dean Latimer
Art by Jose Bea
"The Frog Prince!" ★1/2
Story and Art by Bill DuBay
"Eye of the Beholder" ★★★
Story and Art by Gary Kaufman
"The Lurker in the Deep!" |
Weird occurrences happen aboard the ship that put Vampi on guard, but she's a bit smitten with the host and goes with the flow until Triton undresses and bares his Chaos-tattooed chest. Triton explains that he was saved from drowning by Demogorgan and is now the creature's gofer, bringing it tasty snacks now and then, but that shouldn't stop him from having a little sexual merriment now and then, should it? Just then, the hideous beast rises from the depths and terrorizes the ship; Vampi grabs an axe and starts whacking. The monster, jealous of Vampi's advances on its/her beau, Triton, snatches the man and heads for the bottom. Vampi and Pendragon are left drifting in a lifeboat while, thousands of miles away, Adam Van Helsing announces to his father that he's in love with Drakulon's favorite emissary and is going to find her, no matter what it takes.
"The Lurker..." |
The updates on Demogorgan's status at the bottom of the ocean ("Now she's hungry," "Now she's sleepy," "Now she's mad as hell") reminded me of the classic interludes in Airplane where we flash back, now and then, to Howard Jarvis waiting for Ted to come back to the taxi. "Meanwhile, back at R'lyeh!" The creature design couldn't be more hilarious had it been crafted by Larry Buchanan. I'm stunned by how gorgeous Gonzalez's Vampi art is and doubly stunned by how comical Pendragon and Conrad Van Helsing look. Did the Muppet Show know that Statler and Waldorf were moonlighting?
"From Death's Dark Corner!" |
Jose Bea, who will very soon become a Warren regular and a fan favorite, sees his first published work with "The Silver Thief and the Pharoah's (sic) Daughter" and it's a good one. The tale of Ramses and his vault filled with untold riches, "The Silver Thief..." is a text-heavy but totally engrossing historical fantasy with fabulously detailed Bea graphics. Scripter Dean Latimer (in his only Warren appearance) obviously knew his Egyptian history like the back of his hand but someone at Warren decided it was Pharoah, not Pharaoh (it's misspelled at least four times, including the cover and contents page!).
"The Silver Thief and the Pharoah's Daughter" |
A 14th-Century countess wonders why the men won't look at her in "that way" anymore, so she plots a way back to beauty. The countess sees a gorgeous, long-tressed girl working in the fields and has her taken to the castle, where she orders her staff to remove from the girl whatever they need to transform the countess into a beauty. Lightning strikes twice as Gary Kaufman writes and illustrates a very original fairy tale nearly as effective as his classic "Mad Jack's Girl." Equal parts humor and horror, "Eye of the Beholder" is a weird roller-coaster ride, deriving most of its power from the deconstruction of the innocent maiden and the abject selfishness of the countess. The final line is a hoot. Special mention must be made of the cover, the illustration within the colored border, a striking design that made the Warren titles stand out from the rest in the mid-1970s. Once again, Vampirella proves to be the best magazine of the three this time out.-Peter
"Eye of the Beholder" |
The letters this issue are fun. One writer could have been reading our blog posts, since he praises the same writers we do and criticizes the ones we don't like. Another sent a nude photo of his secretary, who supposedly resembles Vampirella. It is not published, but "Uncle Creepy thinks she ought to work in a library because she's well stacked. Cousin Eerie just drooled."
"No Fair!"
(Reprinted from Creepy #22)
"Spawn of the Cat People"
(Reprinted from Creepy #2)
"On the Wings of a Bird"
(Reprinted from Creepy #36)
"Tough Customers!"
(Reprinted from Creepy #35)
"Pursuit of the Vampire!"
(Reprinted from Creepy #1)
"The Judge's House!"
(Reprinted from Creepy #5)
"Grub!"
(Reprinted from Creepy #28)
"Monster Rally!"
(Reprinted from Creepy #4)
John Pederson |
"Fair Exchange"
(Reprinted from Eerie #9)
"Deep Ruby!"
(Reprinted from Eerie #6)
"Spiders are Revolting!"
(Reprinted from Eerie #26)
"In Close Pursuit"
(Reprinted from Eerie #30)
"Nor Custom, Stale..."
(Reprinted from Eerie #12)
"The Monument"
(Reprinted from Eerie #3)
"Fly!"
(Reprinted from Eerie #7)
Aslan |
"The Origin of Vampirella" ★1/2
Story by J.R. Cochran
Art by Jose Gonzalez
"The Curse of Circe"
(Reprinted from Vampirella #6)
"Goddess from the Sea"
(Reprinted from Vampirella #1 )
"The Curse"
(Reprinted from Vampirella #9)
"Snake Eyes"
(Reprinted from Vampirella #8)
"Forgotten Kingdom"
(Reprinted from Vampirella #4)
"The Origin of Vampirella" |
(when Vampi's boyfriend refuses to aid her in her killing of a Gronos--a boar-like creature) "Love without honor is empty... killing the Gronos would be like killing something in myself."
"The Origin..." |
(Again, the undead boytoy) "Do you wonder at my strength, wind tossed creature your struggles amuse me, wench! Truly amuse me!" (and, no, I didn't accidentally omit punctuation)
We also get a whole lot of Jose Gonzalez's good girl art, lots of Vampi posing, looking into the distance, hand on ass, reclining on the ground, etc. The entirety of "The Origin of Vampirella" is a chore to slog through. A little trivia on the cover, stolen from David Horne's Gathering Horror: this cover was originally supposed to grace issue one until James Warren ixnayed the Aslan and commissioned Frazetta to whip up something magical. I think Warren made a good decision, but this cover is striking as well.-Peter
Jack-Come on Peter, this is better than the Ackerman story! The art is very impressive and it doesn't read like it was written by a 12-year-old. I don't get how this is an origin story, though--are we supposed to take that Vampi's sadness over her lost love propelled her to hop in a spaceship and head for Earth? As I recall, the first version of the story was a Superman swipe. This time, it doesn't make any sense. But the art is smokin'.
Next week... The Cease Fire |
Don McGregor is a writer who often tries to insert politics into his stories, often with mixed results. EC had been very successful with its tackling of subjects in Shock SuspenStories, but Warren and McGregor often whiff at it. The plot line of "Lost and Found" reminds me much of an episode of the television show Fringe where a group of criminals are able to use a machine to change matter enough to enable them to go through a bank safe, only for it to run out of time as they escape and one guy gets stuck coming out.
ReplyDeleteVictor de la Fuente was a very accomplished Spanish artist who has his sole original Warren story with "I Am Dead, Egypt, Dead". His return approximately a decade later to Warren was actually due to them reprinting work he had done in Europe, the series "Haxtur" and "Haggarth" in particular. Around this time Warren was so strapped for cash that they reprinted many works from foreign artists to reduce the number of actual new stories to be drawn. Both Haxtur and Haggarth are quite strong and far outdo any of the dreary original content left in Eerie by that time.
Very excited to see the arrival of Jose Bea to Warren. I think no other Warren artist can compare to just how bizarre and out of this world Bea can get with his artwork and storytelling style (as he will also write many of the stories he does). Not really featuring any monsters or non-human creatures, this story is only a small hint at what is to come from him. "Eye of the Beholder" is quite the highlight, one of my favorite Warren stories. Kaufman does such an effective job both with the writing and artwork, and it is quite horrifying as we see what the Countess becomes.
Maybe it’s because I’ve always been more into the art than the stories, but I’m just WAY more tolerant of terrible comics writing than you guys are. From an early age I learned that Sturgeon’s Law holds especially true for comics : well written stories are BY FAR the exception to the rule. If a crap story is just a frame to hang some excellent art on, I am totally okay with it! I’ll take that combo over the alternative (good story with awful art) any day of the week. When the art is as good as in these early Ploog and Brunner jobs, I can put up with just about any amount of poorly plotted, un-grammatical, cliche-filled, sub-Lovecraftian nomenclature-spouting, typo-riddled nonsense, and still be a happy camper.
ReplyDeleteOn the other hand, ‘The Fade-Away Walk’ is quite bad in both respects. I know McGregor was just starting out but I was kinda shocked by how poor this was. As if the story wasn’t confusing enough, the narration kept switching tenses back and forth and Sutton’s slapdash staging of the climax on Mt. Rushmore just baffled me. As a team, both gents will be delivering much better stories soon enough, both here at Warren and in Marvel’s VAMPIRE TALES.
One of the sweeter developments over the past few years has been seeing both of you gradually coming around to appreciating Grandenetti’s distinctive talents. For sure, he could be hit-and-miss, but when he was ‘On’ he really was something special.
Peter’s comment about Gonzalez’s old dudes looking like Muppets is dead-on! I would say there is a weird, mushy cartooniness to his stuff in general, that is a little bit at odds with the ‘sexy horror’ vibe of the strip, especially in these early stories. Even Adam isn’t immune to the strangely-proportioned ‘Muppet Effect’; he sometimes looks like a realistic Alain Delon head sewn onto a rag-doll body. Not saying I don’t like it —it’s part of his overall charm — it’s just a bit odd.
The ‘new’ Vampi origin is superior to FJA’s amateur-hour original ‘story’ by several orders of magnitude, by default. This version was re-dialogued by Budd Lewis a few years later — my memory is that it smooths out some of Cochran’s more awkward dialogue.
I like these Jones-esque Gary Kaufman jobs a lot. I need to to Google him, don’t know much about the guy.
Those Enrich and Sanjulian covers are quite nice, aren’t they. A little preview of splendid Things To Come over the next few years.
-b.t.
b.t.-
ReplyDeleteI can be tolerant of bad stories if they have great artwork as well. Most of Tom Sutton's stuff adorns bad Lovecraft pastiches but I will admit that I'm very intolerant of fiction (even comic book fiction) where I feel like the writer deems me an idiot (not that I'm not...). The Grandenetti thing took me completely by surprise (again, here's a case of style over subject winning me over) and I still can't explain it. Those Vampi covers are insanely good.
Quid-
Joe Bea's finest hour (in my memory at least) is coming up, illustrating perhaps the biggest rip-off story of all time. Stay tuned.
I did a piece for a British horror comics fanzine years ago on the Eerie series and there's some really awful stuff coming up!
Hmm, now I have to think of what that Bea story could be! I think his finest hour is "The Other Side of Heaven', which is quite possibly the strangest story in the history of Warren, although that's a good 15 issues or so of Vampi away at this point.
ReplyDeleteMaybe I've never read it, but the first Jose Bea story is automatically a welcome thing to me. I don't think they ever had a spookier artist.
ReplyDelete