The EC Reign Month by Month 1950-1956
54: December 1954
+ Best of 1954
Feldstein |
A Special "Flying Saucer Report" Issue ★★
Stories by Al Feldstein
Art by Wally Wood, Reed Crandall, Joe Orlando, and George Evans
A whole issue of this otherwise excellent science fiction title devoted to the "truth" behind dozens of UFO sightings and plane crashes is, in my mind at least, a waste of time, energy, and paper (the time and energy being my own). Fortunately, there are lots of pretty pitchers to absorb between the startling facts of the "British overseas airways Comet-jet liner" that crashed and killed all 43 passengers near Calcutta in 1952
(a quick Wiki look reveals that the crash actually took place in 1953 and the cause was a severe storm) and the little fishing boy who witnesses a silver dish gliding over him one day and all the similar-sounding reports in between. The issue also comes complete with a plea from the EC staff to the United States Air Force to "tell us the truth about the flying saucers."
Gold Key managed to squeeze thirteen issues out of this slim idea a decade later but it's a lot easier to accept a publisher like GK trotting out something like this, not the guys that gave us classic adaptations of Ray Bradbury. --Peter
Jack: The flying saucer hysteria of the early '50s really is hard to comprehend today, isn't it? Imagine thinking that the government was covering something up, or not investigating something, or--oh, you get the point. I love Al's refrain of "it's important" when he mentions a particular fact, or "actual quotes" of pilots saying things like, "there's one of those things again." I wasn't all that impressed with the art, either, and thought it did not go well with the narrative, such as it was. All in all, this is a terribly dated issue that really doesn't reward today's reader.
Ingels |
"The Prude" ★★★
Story by Carl Wessler
Art by Graham Ingels
"Numbskull" ★ 1/2
Story by Carl Wessler
Art by Bernie Krigstein
"Audition" ★ 1/2
Story by Carl Wessler
Art by Jack Kamen
"A Work of Art!" ★★
Story by Carl Wessler
Art by Jack Davis
Well, folks, we've got trouble right here in River City! Actually, it's the little town of Northton that is suffering under the tyranny of "The Prude," a self-righteous man by the name of
"The Prude" |
A cruel man recalls how he loved to trap and torture animals in the jungle before killing them, all the while thinking of the people he had known who had wronged him. One day, he falls in one of his own traps and the ants get their revenge, leaving him nothing but a bleached skull.
Bernie gets Ghastly. ("Numbskull") |
Ethel Stark, a pretty teen who plays a mean clarinet, follows bandleader Phil Vitale around and begs him to let her be in his all-girl band. When she says she'll kill herself, he saves her the trouble and injects her with something that makes her a zombie. She thinks you have to be dead to join the band but quickly learns that it's actually an "all-ghoul" band that is anxious to feast on the nubile musician.
Not another Jack Kamen story! ("Audition") |
Mortician Jarvis Edwards considers every body he prepares for burial to be "A Work of Art!" so he is disappointed when his son in law becomes his apprentice and wants to cut corners to make more money. After Jarvis has a mild heart attack, he becomes obsessed with his own death, worrying that his son-in-law will do a poor job on his corpse. He sees something in a magazine that intrigues him and, after sending off many mysterious orders by mail, he drops dead; his daughter and son in law discover that he built a robot mortician in the basement to make sure the job is done properly.
That's it? He built a robot? This story was going along so nicely until Wessler fumbled on the goal line. A robot! How disappointing. I was picturing that Ray Bradbury story where the guy ends up stuck in the mechanical coffin that digs its own grave. Now, that was a memorable image! Too bad this one isn't. The final issue of Haunt of Fear is a big yawn.--Jack
The disappointing finish to the final story in Haunt of Fear. ("A Work of Art!") |
Peter: So how does The Haunt of Fear fare on its last voyage? Only so-so, I'm afraid. Even though "The Prude" comes with the oh-so-subtle underlying message, I found it to be delightfully sick, especially its closing panel ("Why, Mr. Forbisher! Don't you know there are laws about that sort of thing!") and its Grade-A Ghastly visuals. Bernie Krigstein has been lights out since showing up in the EC bullpen but "Numbskull" (with its numbskull script) is his first stumble, a really bad tale that accentuates the sketchiness and cartoony style that Krigstein has actually shown to good effect in previous contributions. It doesn't help that the protagonist is so evil as to be unbelievable (he goes all the way to Africa to torture animals because of some bad personal experiences?). "A Work of Art!" could pass as a Bradbury adaptation; it's got that small town everyman vibe to it and, a rarity, no real villain. The only five-page horror story to appear in an EC title, "Audition" is supremely dumb, an occurrence that seems to happen in some kind of alternate reality where bandleaders have need for zombies and ghouls. So, it's sad to see the horror titles ending but, and I've said this before, if this was the direction Wessler and Oleck were taking the line, it was time to die.
Kurtzman |
"Alice in Wonderland!" ★★ 1/2
Story by Lewis Carroll
Adapted by Harvey Kurtzman
Art by John Tenniel and Jack Davis
"Howdy Dooit!" ★★★
Story by Harvey Kurtzman
Art by Bill Elder
"Pot-Shot Pete---" ★★★
Story and Art by Harvey Kurtzman
(Reprinted from Billy the Kid Adventure #9, March 1952)
"Stalag 18!" ★★ 1/2
Story by Harvey Kurtzman
Art by Wally Wood
When young Alice chases a rabbit and falls down a rabbit hole, the results are unpleasantly messy. She next tries to climb through the looking glass, but it smashes to bits. She has similar difficulties when trying to go through a tiny door. Finally making it to Wonderland, Alice attends a tea party and gets close up to the white rabbit, who looks an awful lot like Bugs Bunny. Bugs reads the poem called "Jabberwocky," but "Alice in Wonderland" doesn't think much of it. In the end, it all turns out to be a dream, so Alice is dragged off to see a shrink.
"Alice in Wonderland" |
Jack Davis's take on the classic Tenniel art style is funny and I liked the Bugs Bunny cameo. "Alice in Wonderland!" breezes by, more amusing than hilarious.
How Jose met his wife. ("Howdy Dooit!") |
How Jack met his wife. ("Pot-Shot Pete---") |
Yucca Pucca Gulch's "Pot-Shot Pete" is back, and this time he has to bring in the McYetNit Boys! He must avoid a gun-happy young Gunzel and a smooch-happy young blonde, but in the end he brings in the McYetNit Boys, who turn out to be two little lads who had to make it home in time for supper.
Another "Pot-Shot Pete" reprint is welcome, since Kurtzman's work is so creative and absurdly funny.
How Peter met his ex-wife. ("Stalag 18!") |
Wood's art is the highlight of "Stalag 18!" but since I've never seen the movie I don't really get the gags.--Jack
Melvin Enfantino: I'm afraid I didn't laugh out loud, guffaw, or chortle this time out. The only snickers were drawn from the page where Alice tries to get the whole "large room, small door, big key, tiny panel" routine down. Otherwise, this was a very weak issue; in fact, if not for the cover, I'd have pegged it as a Panic. That cover's a classic though.
THE BEST EC STORIES OF 1954!
JACK
1 "Fire Trap!" (Crime SuspenStories #20)
2 "Star Light, Star Bright!" (Vault of Horror #34)
3 "Squeeze Play" (Shock SuspenStories #13)
4 ". . . And All Through the House . . ." (Vault of Horror #35)
5 "Shoe-Button Eyes!" (Vault of Horror #35)
6 "Flesh Garden!" (MAD #11)
7 "Starchie!" (MAD #12)
8 "Indisposed!" (Haunt of Fear #25)
9 "The Pioneer" (Weird Science-Fantasy #24)
10 "The Privateer" (Piracy #1)
JOSE
1 “Star Light, Star Bright!”
2 “Squeeze Play”
3 “…And All Through the House…”
4 “Dragged Net” (MAD #11)
5 “More Blessed to Give…” (Crime SuspenStories #24)
6 “Gasoline Valley” (MAD #15)
7 “Tick Dracy” (Panic #5)
8 “Dog Food” (Crime SuspenStories #25)
9 “The Squealer” (Crime SuspenStories #25)
10 “Swamped” (Haunt of Fear #27)
PETER
1 "Starchie!"
2 "More Blessed to Give..."
3 "Squeeze Play"
4 " . . . And All Through the House. . ."
5 "Pipe Dream" (Vault of Horror #36)
6 "Prairie Schooner" (Tales from the Crypt #40)
7 "Robinson Crusoe" (MAD #13)
8 "3 Dimensions" (MAD #12)
9 "Fall Guy" (Shock SuspenStories #12)
10 "Woman Wonder" (MAD #10)
Next Week . . . A very bad day for Sgt. Rock! |
I'm a big fan of your "best of" posts. Here's my best of 1954:
ReplyDelete1. The Flying Machine (WSF #23)
2. Pipe Dream (VOH #36)
3. Squeeze Play (SS #13)
4. Starchie (M #12)
5. The Whipping (SS #14)
6. 3-Dimensions (M #12)
7. A Kind of Justice (SS #16)
8. The Children (WSF #23)
9. The Kidnapper (SS #12)
10. The Catacombs (VOH #38)
-- Jim
My favorite aspect of doing these blogs is putting together the best of lists. Coming soon: my Top Ten list of Top Ten Lists.
ReplyDeleteSo I was (and still am, but not as much) a UFO/flying saucer fanatic, and yet I always found this issue of Weird Science-Fantasy very boring. Al Feldstein basically sat down with and got all his details from a UFO expert at the time, I think David Keyhoe was his name. Kurtzman handled the non-fiction work a hell of a lot better than Feldstein (certainly the shorter length helped).
ReplyDeleteAgreed with you guys on how mediocre this last issue of Haunt of Fear is. The first story is decent but the other 3 are awful. A Work of Art is clearly a reworking of Bradbury's the coffin, but in much less interesting fashion.
Jack's love for Johnny Craig shows quite a bit, as 4 of his top 5 stories were either drawn by or written by him! Good to see "The Pioneer" get some love, I always enjoyed that story quite a bit and find it very underrated.
As for my own top 10... I will actually mix it up a little and
1. And All Through the House - V35
2. Any Sport in a Storm - V38
3. Understudies - CSS21
4. About Face - H27
5. The Children - WSF23
6. Fish Story - WSF23
7. A Sound of Thunder - WSF25
8. Squeeze Play - SS13
9. The Pioneer - WSF24
10. My Brother's Keeper - SS16
I don't know about the QUALITY of them, but I don't see the problem with the general idea of UFO story dramatizations in a horror comic (once in a while, at least, or in this case, a single issue about them). So Quiddity99's comment makes sense to me, since it's not about how wrong it is to use them in the first place, only the quality of them.
ReplyDeleteDonald Keyhoe was one of the biggest ufology figures at the time, so yes, he probably was the one who was consulted.
Q99, thanks for sharing your list! I'm often frustrated with doing these lists because I end up with about 20 stories and then have to start cutting. Some of the ones I cut are as good as the ones I leave on.
ReplyDeleteGrant, I agree with you that a UFO story is fine as long as it's a good one. Unfortunately, this issue is boring, depsite the art.